Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide

This article is about ten different fish that are best when smoked. In addition, there is information about how to smoke the fish and what wood is best to use.
By
Jeremy Bivens
Jeremy Bivens
Research Writer
Jeremy Bivens is a passionate writer and grilling enthusiast. He's been working as a freelance journalist for over 15 years now and has a particular interest in food writing read more
reviewed
Reviewed By
Bruce Williams
Bruce Williams
Expert Consultant
Claims that grilling is the art that he has been learning all his life long and is not planning to stop. Has been grilling for as long as he can remember. Author of numerous read more
Last updated: August 29, 2023
GrillGuru is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Smoking fish to preserve the meat or enhance the flavor has been a popular cooking method worldwide for centuries. It was popularized for commercial use within the past four hundred years but was a traditional practice for thousands of years. Now, when we smoke fish, we are typically doing it as a way to enhance the flavor of the meat and create a unique meal rather than preserve food. When you begin to get interested in smoking fish, there are certain things that every beginner (and every expert) should know. This includes how to smoke fish, the best fish to smoke, and how different fish react to smoking. In this article, you will get information about the top 10 best fish to smoke, as well as background information about smoking fish so you can start smoking like a pro. So, without further ado, let’s explore the delicious (and slow) cooking method of smoking fish!

Can you smoke any fish?

Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide
Usually, you can tell whether a fish will taste good smoked depending on its fat content. The fat content of the fish can tell a person whether or not the fish will absorb the flavors from the smoke and the wood.

For the most part, many people who smoke fish agree that you can smoke almost any type of fish. However, there are fish that maintain their integrity and taste better after being smoked and other fish that do not taste as delicious. So, yes, you can smoke any fish, but there are fish that are heralded as better when smoked than others. To tell what type of fish is better smoked, you have to look at the fish meat itself. A higher fat content or a fattier fish will result in a more delicious smoked fish. This is because the fat in the fish is what absorbs the flavors from the wood and the smoke. Therefore, fish with a higher fat content hold the smoked flavor better than fish that have less fat. Leaner fish are only able to absorb a little bit of the smoky flavor, resulting in a milder taste. Some smokers are even designed for use with fatty fish, like the Pit Boss Pellet Grill.

Some people, however, prefer a leaner fish to smoke because the flavor does not have the same strength as the fattier fish. Although there are people who prefer leaner fish for the mild flavor, most people prefer the fattier fish and stronger flavors. In general, there are some types of fish that most people think are better than any others when smoked. These fish have been traditionally and commercially smoked for centuries and have created a name for themselves as fantastic, unique, and delicious meals all around the world. Of course, a good smoker is crucial to getting the perfect meal from smoked fish. It is better to invest in one that is a bit better and might cost more than a cheap one that will fall apart. There are different kinds of smokers, like charcoal smokers, commercial smokers, and travel smokers, so spend some time figuring out what you need. If you are looking for a larger smoker to take your smoking to the next level, check out the Camp Chef Pellet Smoker, which is large enough to hold big pieces of meat but not too huge like a commercial-sized smoker.

Top ten fish to smoke

There are many types of fish that are well-known for being delicious when smoked. This is regardless of any fat content or another method of cooking. We are going to focus solely on the ten best fish to smoke and why. Many of the fish on our list are fatty fish because they are more popular than the leaner types. In the following section, you will find a list of 10 different fish, each with their explanation and information about why they are on the list of the ten best fish to be smoked. On our list of the top 10 fish to smoke, you will find salmon, mackerel, trout, cod, tuna, sea bass, sturgeon, bluefish, Rockfish, and sardines. In the section below each fish, you will find information relating to the best way to smoke it, types of wood to use, and other background information about smoking that fish.

Salmon

In the early 1800s, smoked salmon began to become eight popular food across the United States of America. The salmon industry was primarily located on the west coast of the nation, with most of the salmon caught in the Pacific, around Alaska and Oregon. However, during World War II, the message of preservation and salting the fish had to change. A new form of smoking and salting to preserve the fish was created so that it could travel longer distances and not spoil. Although, smoked salmon is not a new food. Indigenous native tribes in the Americas caught and smoked salmon Trusted Source Salmon | Traditional Animal Foods of Indigenous Peoples of Northern North America - Animals - Fish - Searun Fish Salmon is also said to be an important source of food for the Kitimat Haisla, Malecite, Kwakiutl, Nootka (Nuu-chah-nulth), Vuntut Gwich’in of Old Crow, Champagne and Aishihik, cultures from the central coast of British Columbia, cultures from southern British Columbia and northern Washington (Prehistoric period) including the Marpole, Strait of Georgia cultures, Mid-Columbia Indians and cultures from the North Pacific coast. Salmon fishing was an important economic activity for the Malecite, and was one of the most important sources of food for the Shuswap, especially those in close proximity to the Fraser River and Canyon. Salmon was an important and reliable source of food for the Southwest Alaskan Yupik, who consumed several different species. Archeological remains identifying human use found salmon from Oregon to Alaska. traditionalanimalfoods.org and also considered salmon to be a sacred animal and that it needed to be treated with the utmost respect. Rich Romans and Greeks also enjoy smoked salmon quite a bit.

Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide
When it comes to smoking salmon, there are some criteria that you must meet.

If you are planning on smoking a fish, it should be under three years old. This means the fish needs to be relatively young. The fish must then be cured before it is smoked. It can be dry cured or wet cured.

Once the fish is cured, it can be smoked. The larger the piece of fish, the longer it will take to smoke. Many people use flavorful types of wood like cherrywood chips when smoking salmon because it is a fish with high-fat content. This means that the fat in the meat of the fish can absorb the cherrywood flavor, which gives a delicious taste to the meat.

Mackerel

Mackerel is another popular fish that has been smoked for centuries by indigenous populations in the Americas and used modernly as a preserved meat for travel. Mackerel is a commonly eaten fish in the United States, and many people find it is best when smoked. Mackerel should be smoked at a temperature of around 275 degrees Fahrenheit. The fillets should be laid out skin down on the rack. The inside of the fish must reach a temperature of 160 degrees Fahrenheit before it can be taken out of the smoker. Typically, this can take 2 to 4 hours. The best wood to use for smoking mackerel is Alder. This type of wood gives a gentle smoky taste that does not overpower the natural flavor of the mackerel fish itself. This is contrary to other fish like salmon, which do better with sweeter types of would like apple, cherry, or pecan.

Trout

Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide
People love smoked trout because of its mild fish flavor and its flaky texture that pulls apart easily. Many people prefer to smoke their trout using Alder or Oak, but others prefer to use a sweeter wood like Maple or fruitwood. You can also use heavier wood to give a stronger smoky flavor, but the traditional method of smoking trout uses a lighter would such as the ones above.

Trout is another fish traditionally smoked by indigenous populations that lived near bodies of water home to these fish. Trout is a very popular fish and is consumed by people around the world. Many people agree that the best form of trout is smoked trout. When smoking trout, you should expect it to take about one and a half to two hours to completely smoke it. However, this time frame is prone to change depending on the thickness and length of the fillets you are smoking. The internal meat temperature should be 145 degrees Fahrenheit before you remove it from the smoker.

Cod

Cod is well known for being a delicious fish when smoked. It has an incredibly mild flavor, which means people who do not love the taste of fish tend to prefer codfish over other types of smoked fish. Codfish is fantastic at holding on to the smoky flavor of the wood, so it is important to use a flavorful wood when smoking it. You can use a heavier wood like mesquite to create a more intense flavor in the fish, or you can opt for a lighter wood, such as Maple or fruitwood, to make the fish a little bit sweeter and lighter.

The internal temperature of cod should be 140 to 145 degrees when you take it out of the smoker. You should also cook it for 10 minutes per inch of its thickness. That means that if the fish is 5 in thick at its thickest point, you should cook it for 50 minutes, 10 minutes for each inch. You must also flip cod halfway through its cooking time so that it is thoroughly smoked on both sides. Cod also needs to be soaked before it is smoked if it is not getting marinated. Expect to soak your cod in salt water brine for 3 to 4 hours before it is put into the smoker. Remember to dry the fish by patting it down before you smoke it if you brine it.

Tuna

Tuna is an incredibly popular fish, likely one of the most popular, and is eaten around the world in thousands of countries. Tuna fish can come in a variety of different species, and each species has varying types of flavors. For example, yellowfin tuna is fairly common and is found in most simple sushi restaurants or cans at the grocery store. It is known for its fishy flavor. Bluefin tuna, however, is a much rarer tuna that is considered a delicacy in many countries, including the United States. Luckily, all types of tuna take the same amount of time and preparation to smoke! Tuna should have an internal temperature of 140 degrees Fahrenheit when it is finished smoking. Frequently, people say a tuna steak will take about one and a half hours to smoke to the proper internal temperature.

Tuna should be smoked on an elevated smoking rack and be flipped just once at about halfway through the smoking. When it is done, the tuna will be a light brown color with tinges of pink and will easily come apart with a fork. The best wood to smoke tuna with is a nice light and mild-flavored wood. This means most of the fruit words are fantastic to use when smoking tuna. Many people prefer using apple or cherry wood chips for tuna, as the wood flavors help to cut through the fishy taste of tuna, replacing it with a delicious smoky taste.

Sea bass

Sea bass is a pretty popular fish and is consumed around the world in many cultures. In the United States, sea bass is frequently consumed in smoked form. It can take anywhere from two to four hours to smoke a sea bass. This depends upon the thickness of the fillets. Similar to other types of fish, you can tell how long you should be smoking the fish by measuring it at its thickest point and multiplying the thickness by 10 to get the number of minutes to smoke it.

The internal temperature of the fish should be anywhere between 145 degrees to 160 degrees Fahrenheit, which ensures that the inside of the fish has been cooked thoroughly. You should check the internal temperature after about an hour or an hour and a half. Every hour, refill the wood chip tray and add some water to the bowl to keep the fish flavorful. 

Sea bass is a fatty fish, which means it absorbs the smoky flavors easily. It also stays moist longer and is incredibly tender meat. Before you smoke sea bass, you should aim to bring it for 3 to 4 hours in a saltwater solution to help improve the flavor, season the fish, and help break down the muscle fibers so that the fish stays fresher when it is smoked.

Sturgeon

Sturgeon is a wildly popular fish and is well known around the world for its luxurious eggs, also known as caviar. However, caviar is not the only delicious thing that comes from sturgeon. Sturgeon is a delicious fish when it is smoked. The flavor is fairly mild, the meat delicate, and the flavor profile is salty, sweet, and a little bit buttery. Smoking a sturgeon brings out all of these delicious flavors, including the smokey taste created by smoking it. Smoking sturgeon is a fantastic way to eat this fish. Smoked sturgeon should be done smoking when the internal temperature reaches 135 degrees to 140 degrees Fahrenheit. It typically takes about three hours, depending on the thickness of the fish. Sturgeon is traditionally smoked with Maple wood to enhance the sweetness of the fish; however, some people include fruitwood in their smoking chips as well. Sturgeon is an incredibly popular smoked fish and is considered a luxury in many places.

Bluefish

Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide
Bluefish is known for being an oily fish, which is like a combination of a fatty fish and a lean fish. Many people say that it is not a fatty fish because it does not taste fatty, while others say because of its oily consistency that, it is a fatty fish. No matter where you fall on the spectrum of this debate, the meat of bluefish is great for trapping in delicious smoky flavors.

Bluefish should be smoked skin-side down at about 175 degrees Fahrenheit for just about 20 minutes. This depends on the thickness and size of the fillets, but bluefish is typically preferred as a smaller fish when it is smoked. Many people prefer to smoke a smaller-sized bluefish because the larger fish have a huge bloodline that can taint the meat and flavor. The final internal temperature should be 145 degrees Fahrenheit and should be eaten fresh out of the smoker or refrigerated.

Rockfish

Rockfish is a delicious fish that offers sweet and moist meat that is delicious when smoked. It can be marinated or smoked without seasonings added, and it is delicious either way. Rockfish has a flaky white flesh that breaks apart when it is cooked, making it a light and flavorful fish. They have a very mild fishy flavor, which is appealing to people who prefer fish without a seafood taste. It is important to know that consuming Rockfish frequently can cause mercury poisoning Trusted Source Mercury Poisoning: Symptoms, Causes & Treatment Mercury poisoning occurs as a reaction to being exposed to too much mercury, which is an elemental metal found in the environment. my.clevelandclinic.org because of elevated mercury levels Trusted Source Mercury Levels in Commercial Fish and Shellfish (1990-2012) | FDA The table is sorted by MERCURY CONCENTRATION MEAN (PPM) from fish with lowest levels of mercury to highest levels of mercury. You may also sort the table by SPECIES in alphabetical order. www.fda.gov in a variety of fish that live a long time, including tuna, swordfish, and sharks. Rockfish are included in this category. Many governments and states recommend that people only eat one 8 oz serving of Rockfish per month. The internal temperature of Rockfish should be 145 degrees when you take it out of the smoker. Using a lighter type of wood to smoke it is recommended, but for people who like a heavier smoky flavor, a darker wood is fine to use as well.

Sardines

Best Fish to Smoke: Ultimate Guide
Some people who prefer smoked sardines over tinned or fresh sardines like them because they hold the flavor of the smoke very well. Additionally, you can eat a lot of sardines because they have some of the lowest mercury levels of all fish, which means you get all the benefits of eating fish without any of the risks.

All though sardines are incredibly small, they are a favorite when smoked. They take quite a long time to smoke, as they are cooked slowly to enhance the flavor and preserve the meat longer. You can expect to smoke sardines for about 4 to 5 hours over low heat, turning occasionally. They taste best when smoked using hardwood such as almond wood, Maple, apple, or hickory. Many people enjoy smoked sardines as a way to get their omega threes and fatty acids because of the high-fat content in sardines.

Final thoughts

Although we have gone over some of the best fish to smoke, the most popular smoked fish will almost always be salmon. Smoked salmon is a favorite in so many cultures around the world. On the other hand, smoked sturgeon is one of the most luxurious smoked fish, while smoked sardines are likely the most snacked on. All these types of fish have unique flavors that are brought out by smoking them with different types of wood. They can be marinated and dressed up to suit your tastes or be smoked naturally with just a little bit of salt. Whether your favorite fish was on our list of best fish to smoke or not, make sure that you are consuming the fish after it is fully cooked! We hope that you enjoyed it!

References

1.
Salmon | Traditional Animal Foods of Indigenous Peoples of Northern North America - Animals - Fish - Searun Fish
Salmon is also said to be an important source of food for the Kitimat Haisla, Malecite, Kwakiutl, Nootka (Nuu-chah-nulth), Vuntut Gwich’in of Old Crow, Champagne and Aishihik, cultures from the central coast of British Columbia, cultures from southern British Columbia and northern Washington (Prehistoric period) including the Marpole, Strait of Georgia cultures, Mid-Columbia Indians and cultures from the North Pacific coast. Salmon fishing was an important economic activity for the Malecite, and was one of the most important sources of food for the Shuswap, especially those in close proximity to the Fraser River and Canyon. Salmon was an important and reliable source of food for the Southwest Alaskan Yupik, who consumed several different species. Archeological remains identifying human use found salmon from Oregon to Alaska.
2.
Mercury Poisoning: Symptoms, Causes & Treatment
Mercury poisoning occurs as a reaction to being exposed to too much mercury, which is an elemental metal found in the environment.
3.
Mercury Levels in Commercial Fish and Shellfish (1990-2012) | FDA
The table is sorted by MERCURY CONCENTRATION MEAN (PPM) from fish with lowest levels of mercury to highest levels of mercury. You may also sort the table by SPECIES in alphabetical order.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X